Measuring the Real ROI of Generative AI

As a VP of Product, I see the pressure everywhere. Companies are making big investments in generative AI, and leaders are asking a simple question: 

What return are we getting on our AI products?

As product leaders, we stand at the center of this conversation. It’s our job to define, track, and explain the value of the AI features we ship to our customers. But measuring the return on investment (ROI) for a new AI product is not a simple math problem. It goes beyond revenue to include strategic value, customer trust, and the unique risks of this new technology.

It’s easy to get excited about the technology itself, but the real win doesn't come from just shipping a cool feature. It comes from fundamentally changing how our customers solve their problems. Consequently, we need to do more than just add AI. We must also deliver a product that transforms our customers' workflows and creates real, measurable value for them.

This post is a practical guide for product managers. It will help you measure the complete picture of ROI for your AI products, balancing exciting potential with the realities of building and supporting them.

Before you can calculate a return, you must understand the full investment required to bring an AI product to market. This goes far beyond the initial price of an API or engineering salaries. A true calculation of the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) must include the high, ongoing cost of infrastructure needed to run powerful AI models.

Just as important is the go-to-market investment. Beyond the technology, you must account for the cost of enabling the entire organization, from training sales and support teams to creating clear customer documentation and marketing a complex new capability. This investment is critical because, without strong customer success and market adoption, even the best technology will fail to find its audience and deliver a return.

Once you have a clear picture of your total investment, the next step is to measure the benefits your product delivers. It's easy to get lost in vague promises of "smarter software," so you must focus on concrete results. To prove the feature's specific impact, you can use A/B testing to see how key customer behaviors, like conversion or engagement, change with the new feature.

The true measure of innovation, however, is the new value you create. Are customers able to do something they couldn't do before? This is what unlocks new, defensible revenue streams. While you wait for long-term revenue to materialize, you can track leading indicators of success. High adoption rates, positive user feedback, and frequent usage all signal that customers are finding real value in your AI product.

A positive ROI on paper can be quickly erased if your AI product fails in the real world. A modern ROI calculation isn't complete until it's adjusted for the unique risks of putting AI in your customers' hands. You must be prepared for new regulations like the EU AI Act, which directly impact products sold in Europe and require a budget for compliance and building transparent features.

Beyond regulations, you must protect your customer’s trust. If your AI product gives bad advice or generates inappropriate content, that trust can be lost forever. The "cost of error" for your product is a key part of your risk assessment. Finally, you have to plan for "drift"—the risk that your model's performance will get worse over time as real-world data changes. Constant monitoring and a plan for retraining are essential product management functions to prevent a beloved feature from becoming a frustrating one.

Ultimately, measuring ROI isn't a passive, bean-counting exercise, but rather, an act of leadership. Our role is to be the bridge between our product's technology and our company's business goals. This means we must be master storytellers who can show the human impact behind the numbers with compelling before-and-after stories from our customers.

At the same time, we need to be disciplined strategists. Not every AI product idea will be a winner. We should treat our initiatives like a venture capitalist does: make small bets to test hypotheses with real customers, and double down only on what shows real market promise. Killing a failing pilot early is a good ROI decision.

This all comes together in a continuous rhythm of review. ROI is not a one-time calculation. By setting up regular, quarterly reviews of our AI product's performance, cost, risk, and customer feedback, we can steer our strategy with confidence.

To bring this all together, I like a simple framework like FAIR ROI. It forces a complete assessment of your product's value:

As product leaders, our role is more important than ever. By focusing on the customer and adopting this rich, strategic view of ROI, we can make better decisions, build truly valuable products, and deliver lasting success to our organizations.

What are your biggest challenges in measuring the ROI of the AI products you build? Share your thoughts in the comments.

Want to learn more about the many ways AI can supercharge product management and development? Subscribe to Filip’s newsletter for AI-powered PMs at GenAI Works.